Question by abnjim5: Is Alcoholics Anonymous more effective than Cognitve Behavioral Therapy?
Much debate exists about which model is more effective in treating the problem of drug addiction. Some say AA is the only treatment that “works” while others choose the more human friendly non-religious CBT. AA uses rigid spiritual concepts based on their 12 steps and conducts their AA meetings on strict formats that were written seven decades ago. In AA “labels” like alcoholic are used which still holds a high degree of social stigmatism. Cognitive Behaviour programs like SMART (self-management and rehab treatment) sees substance abuse as a behaviour that can be changed, not a disease. CBT self-help methods are solidly based in comtemporary science and open discussions are encouraged. AA tells it members and “newcomers” that they need to find a higher power or god and relying on “self will” is bad and will lead to relapse.

If you were having problems with drugs, which would you choose for help, AA or CBT?

Best answer:

Answer by synchronicity915
I think it depends on the person.

Answer by dinoduos
AA is a bunch of BULLSH!T its nothing but a bunch of drunks leaning on each other trading one crutch for another you dont need them or a “higher power”its like another form of brainwashing

Price of Addiction: New opioid treatment can work wonders but there are limits …
Methadone is the best-known treatment for managing opioid addiction, both to heroin and prescription painkillers. But it's not the only one or even the most effective for many addicts. Another drug therapy — buprenorphine, which goes under the brand …
Read more on Portland Business Journal (blog)

HOWLEY: de Blasio daughter's drug abuse video is what's wrong with young …
De Blasio's daughter Chiara, 19, whose problems were shielded during the campaign while her father cut a popular commercial with her brother, admitted to drug abuse in a cloying Christmastime video that evoked sympathy for her “depression. … “When I …
Read more on Daily Caller

Richland company offers drug test kits to parents
Hospitals, government agencies and other companies in the region also provide drug-testing services, whether it's for work place safety or to treat addiction. Chapman-Rosa's sister Shannon Davari works for her, and she routinely kept a test kit at home …
Read more on Mid Columbia Tri City Herald

A new kind of addict: Methadone clinics find new mission in fight against …
… on painkillers are lining up for methadone, a synthetic version of morphine that gained acceptance in the 1960s as way to wean addicts off heroin. Now the drug has found a new mission in the fight against opioid-based prescription painkillers, the …
Read more on WRCB-TV

Greek drug addicts get high in the consumption room
A member of a medical team holds equipment provided to people who will shoot hard drugs in the consumption room, a room where addicts can shoot up under supervision, on Nov. 25 in Athens. One month ago Okana, a Greek organization funded by the …
Read more on USA TODAY

by IFRC

Among prescription painkillers, drug abusers prefer oxycodone
A nationwide survey of opioid drug abusers in rehab indicates that because of the high it produces, the prescription painkiller oxycodone is the most popular drug of choice. Hydrocodone, also prescribed to treat pain, is next in line. In all, some 75 …
Read more on Washington University in St. Louis News

With moratorium on opiate addiction drug, city invites broader discussion on …
Some city councilors want that time to review the city's regulations on drug addiction treatment facilities and, if needed, pass new rules regarding buprenorphine treatment. Under state law, the moratorium could be extended an additional 180 days if …
Read more on Bangor Daily News

With Rise Of Painkiller Abuse, A Closer Look At Heroin
Abuse of prescription painkillers is a "growing, deadly epidemic," according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. On Oct. 24, the Food and Drug Administration recommended … Opioids — derived from opium — include morphine, oxycodone …
Read more on NPR

Aztec Motel to close, reopen as women's drug treatment center
Breanna Shafer is all smiles after getting a place to stay at the Aztec Motel in this 2010 photo. The Aztec Motel was a refuge for homeless people to get back on their feet before getting an apartment. (The Gazette/Jerilee Bennett) …
Read more on Colorado Springs Gazette

Relapse Prevention for Painkiller Abuse – http://drugrehabcenter.com – Relapse Prevention for Painkiller Abuse – Call our Toll-Free Recovery Hotline at 1-800-839-1682 and discover the best treatment …

Vicodin Addiction and Vicodin Abuse – http://drugstrategies.org Vicodin Addiction and Vicodin Abuse – Call our Toll-Free Recovery Hotline: 800-839-1682 and discover the best addiction treatment o…

FDA plan to limit painkiller abuse may have impact for patients who need them
While millions of people use prescription painkillers for relief, their abuse has reached epidemic levels in some places. To combat rising addiction rates, the FDA has a new plan to limit the distribution of pain meds, specifically containing hydrocodone.
Read more on PBS NewsHour

Earl Campbell Opens Up About His Addiction To Painkillers And His Campaign …
Ten years ago, if anyone had asked me what I knew about fighting painkiller addiction, I would have shrugged. I always believed that as an NFL player competing at a high level, and later becoming a husband and father, that it was part of my job to …
Read more on The Post Game (blog)

Pain pills can be prescriptions for addiction, death
DETROIT — It typically starts with a visit to the doctor for a backache or to dull pain after surgery, an accident or a sports injury. It ends with addiction. Misuse of prescription painkillers is on the rise, and experts say increasingly, it's …
Read more on USA TODAY

In Focus: Raising awareness of prescription drug abuse
Prescription drug abuse is the fastest-growing addiction problem in the nation, according to experts. In Western New York, an estimated 1 in 5 young adults between the ages of 18 and 25 is either dependent on or abusing prescription painkillers. More …
Read more on Buffalo News

More states focusing on prescription drug problem
Avi Israel has been a frequent and vocal advocate since 2011 for tackling the growing problem of prescription drug abuse, including testimony in 2012 before the U.S. Senate Caucus on International Narcotics Control. His advocacy helped lead to New York …
Read more on USA TODAY

Kansas vs. Missouri in debate over prescription drug abuse
In the Show Me State, according to the group HealthyAmericans.org, the number of deaths mostly related to prescription drug use has tripled since 1999. The state has the seventh highest drug overdose mortality rate in the United States, with 17 per 100 …
Read more on KSHB